Back off plan for boardwalk

Whether a boardwalk would preserve the ecologically sensitive

habitat along the walking trails of the Upper Newport Bay has become

the heated debate of the day.

It’s a good question, and already many have given their answers,

even though the public has had little chance to observe the entire

plan.

To date, there is just not enough information to make a clear

decision on this $4-million plan being proposed by county and city

officials.

Proponents of a man-made pathway up and down the bluffs say it

would allow visitors to the Back Bay to enjoy its beauty and natural

surroundings without destroying it by using unapproved foot paths

that damage vegetation and habitat.

If it could be demonstrated that a Back Bay boardwalk would

protect habitat from the trampling feet of pedestrians and hikers, we

would urge even the most strident of those calling for retention of

the status quo to rethink their opposition.

But if it is demonstrated that it would be of little use and

indeed would harm the environment rather than help it, the idea ought

to be scrapped right away.

The Back Bay is a jewel for all who live in Newport-Mesa and is

home to waterfowl, some endangered like the clapper rail and least

tern, and other wildlife like rabbits, squirrels and coyotes.

The land is a protected wetland estuary that must be guarded. So

it is no wonder that even the smallest of intrusions, like a

boardwalk, would have those who love this natural piece of land

aghast.

What could be more environmentally friendly than dirt trails, they

ask? Indeed, with so few dirt trails left in an area that has reached

its build-out potential, the idea of eliminating even more is

heart-wrenching for those who have seen Newport-Mesa evolve from its

more rural days.

What is clear is to us is that the health and well being of the

Back Bay is the goal of all parties.

It also is clear that we, and the public, do not have enough

information to make an honest decision on the boardwalk.

We urge the council and county officials to retreat a bit. Give

the public a chance to weigh in with their opinions and ideas and

come up with the best plan possible for this most vital resource.