‘Sex’ talk: Opposing critics battle over ‘Sex and the City’
By Stephanie Lysaght, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
PRO: Great clothes. Duh.
“Designer Patricia Field supplies upwards of 300 outfits, each more outrageous than the last, with stiletto shoes that are probably registered as dangerous weapons in some countries.” (Peter Howell, TheStar.com) (Craig Blankenhorn / Associated Press)
PRO: The acting is remarkable.
Sarah Jessica Parker “is spectacularly good. She’s so fragile beneath her sultry poses -- she’s like a little girl dressing up, wriggling from one fabulous outfit to the next, enchanted, but apt to whither in the face of rejection and self-doubt.” (David Edelstein, CBS News) (Rick Maiman / Associated Press)
CON: The acting is terrible.
“Perpetually bitter Miranda feels disappointingly one-dimensional, in both the way she’s written and played.” (Elizabeth Weitzman, New York Daily News) (Rick Maiman / Associated Press)
PRO: Jennifer HudsonÂ’s performance enlivens the film.
“The script does allow one pleasant surprise: the advent of a personal assistant to Carrie, a smart and starry-eyed young émigré to Manhattan played with vim and realism by Jennifer Hudson, virtually the only non-Caucasian in a Manhattan as white as Woody Allen’s.” (Shawn Levy, OregonLive.com) (Peter Foley / EPA)
Advertisement
CON: The male characters are marginalized.
“Unlike the show, which allowed the men to emerge occasionally from the sidelines with lines of actual dialogue, the male characters in the movie stand idly by, either smiling or stripping, reduced to playing sock puppets in a Punch-free Judy and Judy (times two) show. I’m all for the female gaze, but, gee, it’s also nice to talk — and listen — to men, too.” (Manohla Dargis, New York Times) (Jason DeCrow / Associated Press)
PRO: “The film stays true to the series.
“The 2½-hour film doesn’t try to cram in unnecessary plot twists or illogical developments to set it apart from the series. Charlotte doesn’t suddenly become a paralegal in Miranda’s firm (with hilarious results!), and Carrie doesn’t up and decide to run for Congress.” (Bobby Hankinson, Houston Chronicle) (Richard Drew / Associated Press)
CON: The friendships among the women are lacking.
“The show was at its best when it offered, without a great deal of extraneous examination, these glimpses into the nature of friendships between women. The movie needs more of that.” (Stephanie Zacharek, Salon.com) (Craig Blankenhorn / Associated Press)
