Military widows struggle to move on

By Jason George

Oct. 22, 2006 12 AM PT

Chicago Tribune

TONGANOXIE, KAN. — Mo’s Pizza is beginning to fill with the after-church lunch crowd, and Kelly Frantz couldn’t be more uncomfortable.

“I don’t do this very often,” she whispered, ignoring both the cheese slice growing cold in front of her and the people staring in her direction.

“Most of the time I’m outside of Tonganoxie because I want to blend in. And I don’t feel like I can do that here.”

Frantz, 24, drew attention not because she is an actress or fashion model. Frantz’s unwanted celebrity is as unglamorous as it is tragic: She is a war widow.

About 40% of the more than 3,000 U.S. soldiers who have died since Sept. 11, 2001, had a wife or husband waiting for them back home. And for those surviving spouses, who are almost all women, the grieving process is their own.

But within this sisterhood that grows with every casualty, there is a subgroup of young widows in their teens and early 20s. Newly single, but not exactly so, these women say they must strike a balance between being the fallen hero’s wife and being independent -- all while mourning under the microscope.

“When you think of a widow you think of an older lady, maybe 60 or 70, not a 23-year-old,” said Frantz, whose husband, Spc. Lucas Frantz, was killed in Iraq a year ago.

“Starting my life over again obviously wasn’t my choice, but I’m going to go with it,” she said. “I’m not going to hide in the corner of my room.”

Comments such as these show just how much American military widows are speaking out and grieving publicly as never before, said Kathy Upchurch, national vice president of Gold Star Wives of America, an organization that has been supporting military widows since 1945.

“During Vietnam you didn’t talk,” said Upchurch, whose husband was killed there in 1969.

The Internet, support groups and the media widely announcing information on casualties have allowed those left behind to connect with one another, Upchurch said.

“It’s not as stigmatized to go to a grief group. And there’s more available to them to reach out to get help if they want to,” she said.

“They kind of find each other.”

Two years ago last month, as Erin Lamb was celebrating her 21st birthday, her in-laws came to tell her that her husband Spc. Charles R. Lamb of Casey, Ill., had been killed in Iraq.

“Your whole life flips upside down,” she said.

After her husband’s death, Lamb, like others, initially found strength in her community, which wrapped her in a blanket of support. But within months that blanket became a burden.

“You are looked at totally different,” she said, stressing that she did not want to appear ungrateful.

Frantz agreed.

“Right when Lucas died I said, ‘It’ll be good: I’ll live in Tonganoxie and everyone will know me,’ ” she recalled. “But as much as Tonganoxie was there for me -- and they were really there for me -- I get tired.

“After a couple of months, you just have to live your life. You want to go to the grocery store without people coming up to you or looking at you,” Frantz said, gesturing out the window to the B&J; Country Mart, where she and her husband worked and met in 2000.

Living under such a spotlight drove Lamb to leave Illinois.

“In Casey, I didn’t have a chance to grieve,” she explained from her new home near Albany, N.Y. “I don’t regret it, and I’m thankful that I did move.”

It’s a move Frantz said she was ready to take too. “I need to leave Tonganoxie and be a normal person,” she said.

One reason Frantz said she wanted to leave was that she was dating again -- a choice that not everyone in her family and circle of friends agrees with.

“It’s been difficult and hard. Lucas died a hero, and everybody puts him up so high, and it’s hard for me because he was my husband. He was a normal person, but people forget about that,” she said.

“I always knew Lucas never wanted me to be alone in life. I do better with someone beside me.”

Shauna Brown was three months pregnant when the tank her husband, Marine Lance Cpl. Patrick O’Day, was in rolled into the Euphrates River, killing him during the first week of the Iraq war in March 2003. At that time, finding love again was the farthest thing from her mind.

“I think for me, because I was in my first trimester, I kept telling myself I have to stay calm and not lose the only thing I have left,” said the 22-year-old from Temecula, Calif.

Helping her with her grief, thanks to the Internet and e-mail, was Deborah May, who grew up in Homewood, Ill., and whose husband, Staff Sgt. Donald C. May Jr., was killed in the same tank accident as O’Day. The two became instant friends, bonding in their husbands’ deaths and the fact that they were both pregnant.

“We know exactly how each other feels,” Brown said.

Hearing a knock at the front door can be one of the worst sounds to someone who has a spouse in the military, where death is an ever-present fear.

“Military grief is also complex for three key reasons,” said Joanne Steen, co-author of “Military Widow: A Survival Guide.”

Steen, whose Naval Reserve husband was killed on duty in 1992, said military spouses were often young and stationed far from home. But in addition, the person often dies a violent death; sometimes the body can’t be viewed by survivors.

Steen noted that military funerals were often public events, and she cautions surviving spouses to avoid “memorial burnout.”

Elisha Pahnke, 28, of Flat Rock, Ind., said that with the continual requests for appearances from media and parade organizers, being a war widow could be her full-time job -- if she’d let it be.

“And I can’t,” said Pahnke, whose husband, Pvt. Shawn Pahnke, was killed in Iraq in June 2003.

“As much as I want to do stuff like that, it just brings the emotions back too quickly. It’s extremely overwhelming.”

She said she also had to worry about protecting her son, Dean, 3, who was 3 months old when his dad died.

“As much as I want my son involved in that kind of stuff and exposed to it, I don’t want every time it’s Veterans Day or Memorial Day for him to be upset because he sees me cry,” she said.

And there are other challenges for survivors.

About a year after O’Day died, Brown began dating again, but she quickly learned that not everyone is completely comfortable with her widow status.

“He did not understand the whole thing,” Brown said of a man she dated. “He felt weird about me having pictures of Patrick up.”

It was not until later in 2004 that Brown grew closer to someone she said could understand the unusual “baggage” she brings to a relationship. “I actually married another Marine,” she said with an easy laugh.

Marine Cpl. Ray Brown, who was good friends with Patrick before he died, and Shauna married in 2005. They are raising Shauna and Patrick’s daughter, Kylee Marie Patrick O’Day, and a daughter, Makayla Brown, they had together.

The family of four is very happy now, even though Shauna has mixed emotions about Ray’s upcoming deployment to Iraq in March, his second.

“I hate the fact that he has to go again, but it is just something I have to deal with,” she said.

“And at this point, I’m used to having to deal with things. That’s military life.”