Simi Valley to Pay $320,000 to Woman Hurt in Police Chase

Simi Valley agreed Tuesday to pay $320,000 to a woman whose skull was fractured when a truck slammed into her vehicle during a high-speed police chase.

The settlement, authorized by the City Council on Monday night, came the day that jury selection was set to begin in a civil trial.

Mark Hiepler, the attorney for crash victim Shelley Padalecki, said he was convinced that he could have gotten a higher award if a jury heard the case. But Hiepler said he was concerned about the immediate medical needs of his client, who is uninsured and unable to afford much-needed surgery.

“We could go and get a $10-million verdict,” Hiepler said. “But this could go on for years. In the meantime, Shelley sits there without any hope of a future.”

Padalecki, 20, who has been unable to work or go to school since the accident, said she is glad the case is over.

“It’s hard to say, but I actually am looking forward to being able to get the additional surgeries I need right away,” she said through her attorney Tuesday morning.

City officials said they thought they could have prevailed at trial but agreed to a settlement because they were concerned about the possibility of a costly verdict.

“No one can predict what a jury can do,” said Steve Blades, a private Los Angeles attorney who represented the city. “While we did feel confident that we were not legally responsible for her injuries, the case had a tremendous sympathy factor.”

Padalecki was driving home from a wedding reception in April 1999 when the truck crashed into her. The chase had begun when a suspected drunk driver whose lights were not on refused to stop for police. After fleeing at more than 100 mph, the 14-year-old driver crashed into a pole and then hit Padalecki’s vehicle.

It was later determined that the truck was stolen and that the teenager had been under the influence of drugs. He is now serving time at the California Youth Authority.

Padalecki’s skull was fractured and she was in a coma for two weeks. She has undergone two major operations but needs further surgery and rehabilitation, her father said.

Her family sued the city for negligence, saying that police officers acted recklessly by speeding on city streets and through crowded intersections. The suit also alleged that the city’s policy on police chases violated state law by giving officers too much discretion to decide when to pursue fleeing cars.

Simi Valley’s policy, which is similar to others in Ventura County and California, states that an officer can pursue a car when a suspected criminal or traffic violator flees. But officers must balance the seriousness of the offense with the potential dangers of pursuit.

City leaders expressed sympathy for Padalecki but said they do not plan to change their pursuit policy.

“There was an innocent victim and the injuries were extremely bad,” City Atty. David Hirsch said. “But at the same time, we have a policy that we believe meets the requirements of state law and we were prepared to go to trial on that basis.”

California statutes hold that police departments are not liable for damages in claims arising from pursuits as long as they have guidelines for officers on when and how to conduct high-speed chases.

But Hiepler said the policy does not comply with that law because it fails to provide for adequate supervision of and limitations on officers.

Robert Padalecki, who moved his family to Texas after the accident, said he hopes that his daughter’s tragedy will spur police officers to be more careful so the “lives of innocent citizens are not jeopardized.”

Hiepler said that although the suit did not result in any direct changes in Simi Valley’s policy, he is confident that the case made that city and others reassess their police pursuit policies.

“We have forced authorities to look at this policy, which they have completely ignored for years,” he said. “The debate will continue.”