Why Do I Look Like Me? : As early as 2, children notice how they differ from others. Next, they want to know why, what it means. - Los Angeles Times
Advertisement

Why Do I Look Like Me? : As early as 2, children notice how they differ from others. Next, they want to know why, what it means.

Share via
SPECIAL TO THE TIMES

Bill Sparks sat in front of his third-grade class at the 36th Street School in Los Angeles, reading aloud from “The Gingerbread Man,†when, suddenly, he was asked a question that stumped him.

“What color am I?†asked a 9-year-old student. “What color is my skin?â€

The boy, who was Latino, said he already knew his skin was brown, but he wanted to know exactly what shade.

Sparks, who is Anglo, sat there staring at the youngster.

“I just didn’t know,†says the longtime teacher, who is co-chairman of the L.A. Unified School District’s Multicultural Education Committee and has written extensively about children and racial awareness. “We don’t have names for 20 shades of brown, not that I know of.â€

Sparks told the boy he would attempt somehow to find a name, and if he couldn’t, they would huddle together and make one up.

Advertisement

That having been said, seven more children raised their hands and wanted to know their exact colors.

“Not every kid is so observant,†Sparks says. “But some children pick up on everything. They try to understand the world and their place in it. They are trying to make sense of their own individuality and the physical differences they observe between people.â€

It may surprise some adults, but children do observe racial and ethnic differences at an extremely early age.

Research done as early as the 1940s by noted psychologists Kenneth and Mamie Clark--and substantiated by more recent studies by Louise Derman-Sparks (Bill’s wife) and other educators at Pacific Oaks College in Pasadena--indicate that between ages 2 and 3 children begin recognizing differences in characteristics such as skin color, facial features and hair texture.

Advertisement

By the time they enter kindergarten or elementary school, children are headed full throttle toward some level of racial or ethnic awareness. And often, experts say, their observations can be accompanied by attitudes--toward themselves and others.

Some are positive, some negative, depending in large part on who and what influences them.

“Young children ask a lot of questions about (racial) differences,†says Sparks, who believes such questions should be answered by parents and teachers clearly, honestly, with sensitivity and without bias. “They pick up on the responses of adults and they pick up the values of those adults, including biases. They also are influenced by other kids and what they see on TV and in movies.â€

In some cases, children begin placing values on physical differences almost as soon as they notice them, according to former teacher Jackie Carter, editorial director of early childhood publications at Scholastic Inc., in New York. “Because of day care, children in our society are being exposed to these differences at an earlier age,†she says. “Hopefully, parents and teachers will celebrate the differences. Hopefully, they’ll say, ‘Yes, we are all different, isn’t that wonderful.’ â€

Advertisement

For many white children, the stumbling block is overcoming lingering prejudice--some overt, some subtle--handed down from previous generations and passed along from other sources.

For numbers of minority children, the obstacle is negative experiences that occur because they are “different.â€

For both groups, the paths leading to a celebration of differences are intertwined.

The cold reality is that a minority child’s racial awareness often is turbocharged by a negative incident, says Gail Elizabeth Wyatt, a professor of medical psychology at UCLA.

“Such an incident can be devastating,†she says. “I know of one nursery school boy who was called a chocolate bar by one of his peers. He broke into tears.

“Children become teasers when they are quite young. Unfortunately, if a child is somehow different, there’s usually a connotation that he is deficient. It’s a sad way to start your self-concept, feeling there is something wrong with you.â€

By age 6, Wyatt says, many minority children are acutely aware of “power terms,†words with bad intentions--used by others to hurt, anger, provoke and insult by making fun of one’s race or ethnic background.

Advertisement

For their part, white youngsters hear the words, learn them and repeat them, Wyatt says. “If parents don’t intervene, they go on using them. Between the ages of 9 to 11, we have budding racists.â€

In truth, when young children use racial slurs, often the very source is their parents.

“Children are a product of their world,†Wyatt says. “Racism begins at home.â€

None of this is breaking news to Maurice Wire, 27, of Palmdale. A few years ago, before Wire graduated from Azusa Pacific University, he delivered pizzas for a restaurant chain.

One night, he took in a large dose of hand-me-down, juvenile racism.

“When I walked up to deliver a pizza,†says Wire, who is black, “this 7-year-old white kid opened the door. I was standing there, waiting for his father to come over to pay, when the boy referred to me with a racial slur.

“I just stood there.

“The kid tugged on his father’s pants, and repeated the slur two more times. The father looked nervous while I took my time counting out his change. Finally, the guy says, ‘Keep the change,’ and shut his door.

“The change was over $5.

“I just thought, ‘Man, you got caught.’ The boy was just repeating what he’d heard in the past from his father.â€

Wire says he can deal with racism, and he is working to ensure that his own children receive the emotional support they need to do likewise.

Advertisement

A year ago, Wire married Cathy, a Filipino-Mexican-American who has four children by a previous marriage. Two months ago, the couple had a daughter, Catherine.

Once, Wire had to explain to his three stepsons--David, Lance and Daniel--why his hair is “fuzzy†and theirs isn’t.

“Lance, who is 7, wanted me to cut his hair short so it would look like mine,†Wire says. “I cut it short, but it didn’t come close to looking like mine. He was confused and kind of mad.

“I told him, ‘My hair is curly because my parents’ hair is curly,’ that my parents are black. ‘Yours is straight because your parents’ hair is straight,’ that they are Mexican and Filipino.â€

That direct kind of answer is necessary to help young children understand who they are and whence they came, experts say.

“Children need to understand why they are different, what makes them distinct, what group they emanate from,†Wyatt says.

Advertisement

Although children of different ethnic backgrounds sometimes face different obstacles, she says, the overriding issues for children of color is the same: white culture has been established as the norm in this country.

“Children must realize, however, that there is no racial norm for what’s acceptable or appropriate,†she says. “(The norm) should be flexible to include all people.â€

To make sure their two sons understood this, Chris and James Cook of Pasadena began explaining their heritage to each child before his second birthday.

“We told them who we are--I’m Mexican-American and my husband is Creole: French, native American and African-American,†Chris Cook says. “We began teaching them to be proud of their ethnicity. I wanted them to be prepared if anyone said anything racist to them.â€

They didn’t have to wait long. When the Cooks’ oldest son, Christian, was 4, a boy at his day-care center said he wouldn’t play with him because he is black. Christian, outwardly, at least, came away from the incident in better shape than his parents.

“When we heard about it, my husband and I both sat down and cried,†Cook says. “Now, I tell Christian all the time that I love his pretty brown skin. I want him to feel good about himself. And, now, he really has a great sense of pride in his skin color.â€

Advertisement

Conversations between parents and children are essential, Wyatt says, for minority toddlers to make sense out of sometimes puzzling confrontations.

“Most of these children don’t know how to deal with it when they are mistreated because of the color of their skin,†she explains. “They need to have ongoing talks with their parents--things go on everyday at school. The more a parent addresses it, the better.â€

Adds Luz Myles, a probation officer assigned to assist troubled children in the Duarte School District: “If (parents) don’t talk to them, the kids feel as though they have to just take it. And that hurts. It can affect their whole life.

“Sometimes, they turn to gangs--at 8, 9, 10 years old--because the gangs will accept them when they feel no one else will.â€

Overt racism isn’t always to blame for low self-esteem, says Sparks, the co-author with his wife of the book, “Anti-Bias Curriculum: Tools for Empowering Young Children.â€

“There are more subtle messages picked up by kids telling them they are unimportant, or reinforcing a stereotype,†he says. “For example, PA announcements at school may be all in English, even though only 50% of the students understand the English.

Advertisement

“Some people may say everyone was treated equally in that case, but the information didn’t go into every ear because certain children couldn’t process that.â€

The effects of such messages are illustrated, in part, by the numbers of minority children in preschool who prefer to play with white dolls rather than brown or black dolls.

“We have white, Hispanic, black, and Chinese kids in my classes,†says Marjorie Rose, who has worked in the Monrovia School District’s Child Development Center for 11 years. “They all want to play with white dolls. Even the 2- and 3-year-olds choose the white dolls.

“Somehow that’s their idea of what’s good, what’s beautiful.â€

Wyatt says studies have been conducted by the Clarks and other psychologists among young children who have been shown a light-skinned doll and a dark-skinned doll, and were then asked: Who do you want to be like?

“Most of the children picked the fairer-skinned doll,†she says. “In some recent studies, the results have varied, depending on the children involved.â€

White youngsters can be befuddled by uneven treatment toward children of color; Sparks says they begin perceiving such inequities between ages 5 and 7. Their challenge, he continues, is to break free of racism in all of its forms.

Advertisement

“From an early age, white children are often invited to join in prejudice and discrimination,†Sparks says, whether it is based on ethnicity, cliques or name-calling.

If a parent allows a child to participate in name-calling or make generalizations about other people, Sparks says, the seeds of prejudice may be planted.

Given a balanced home environment, Sparks says, children can also recognize racial injustice and react in a constructive manner.

“At 5 and 6, they can sense what is fair and what isn’t fair,†he says. “They can begin to be critical thinkers on cultural and racial issues.

Around the country, many school districts including the Los Angeles Unified have started or are considering adopting anti-bias and multicultural programs.

Last year, a kindergarten class at Cheltenham Elementary School, near Philadelphia, compiled a book for kids that lyrically lists the ways children are alike and different. The book, “We Are All Alike . . . We Are All Different,†will be published by Scholastic this year.

Advertisement

“All the ideas in the book are the kids’,†says teacher Rosalind Goldberg, whose class includes four blacks, three Asians, two Latinos and 16 Anglos.

Lines from the book include:

We are all alike. We are all people.

We are all different. Some of us have darker skin. Some of us have lighter skin.

We are all alike . . . We all have hearts and brains.

According to Goldberg, the children’s awareness is remarkably keen.

“The kids compared themselves to snowflakes,†she says. “They recognize that snowflakes all have six points, but none of them are exactly alike. They know they have their differences and that those differences make them unique. But they are the same, they are all people.â€

Advertisement