Opinion: Juiced on the loose
This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.
While you’re busy digesting the George Mitchell steroid report, the ‘serial news conferences’ accompanying it and the curious mix of apathy and hysteria with which the nation seems to be greeting this long-expected news, take a look back through the archives of Dust-Up, for our debate on steroid use back in March. Halos Heaven proprietor Mat Gleason took the tough-on-enhancers stance:
The hysteria around privacy issues and drug testing is overblown. For years we were told there was no smoke, proof there was no fire. Jose Canseco changed that. His former teammate Mark McGwire fell from the pinnacle of prestige to perennial pariah in record time. What were they hiding? Lots. Why were they hiding it? There is a culture that protects superstars -- and some of the guys racking up big numbers were juicing, no doubt about it.
New York Sun baseball writer Tim Marchman, on the other hand, said let a thousand mystery-skin-creams bloom:
We don’t need to protect ballplayers from themselves and their juiced-up peers. They have a union and other legal mechanisms by which they can do so, to precisely the degree they feel appropriate. If you don’t think that’s good enough, don’t spend any money on baseball. Don’t have any illusions, though, that the game is now different from any other sport, any other high-stress profession, or different from the game we all watched when we were kids.
Meanwhile, our former colleague Matt Welch launches into a locker-room-trashing ‘roid rage over at Reason:
In any case, we now know beyond a shadow of a doubt that if you give a former Senate Majority Leader $2 million a month for more than a year and half, force clubhouse lackeys to testify under threat of $100,000 fine, and have federal prosecutors grant vastly reduced sentences to drug convicts in exchange for cooperating with Mitchell’s private investigation, you can indeed produce circumstantial evidence that Nook Logan (career home runs: 2) and nearly four score others may have taken legal supplements without a prescription to help them recover more quickly after working out, many during a time when such supplements were perfectly acceptable according to Major League Baseball’s own rules. And as a direct result, your teenage daughter might eventually face drug testing if she plays sports, once Congress goes through another thrilling round of reforming government.